Things You Should Know About Idea Stealing-Part 1
19:00
There are plenty of reasons why writers don’t like to share
their work. Negative feedback, or just plain being ignored are two of the
biggest worries. But a lot of writers are also concerned about having their
ideas stolen. And it is a perfectly legitimate fear. We writers work hard to
find and develop our ideas into workable plots. Our ideas are very personal to
us. We pour our hearts and souls into our books. So to have that hard work
stolen from us can be devastating. Now, I’ve been lucky enough that I’ve never
had my ideas stolen. But I know it happens, and I thought that today I would
write about some things writers should be aware of about idea stealing.
I actually have quite a lot to say on the subject, so I’m
splitting this discussion into two parts for length reasons. This week I’ll be
talking about what idea stealing actually is, and how to tell whether you’re
inspired by an idea, or whether you’re just stealing it. And then next time I’ll
be addressing the other side of the issue, where it’s your idea that has been
stolen. So, without further ado, here we go.
You Should Never EVER Steal Someone Else’s Ideas
I’d like to say this straight up front, and I cannot stress just HOW important this is. It is never ok to
steal someone else’s ideas and hard work. It’s perfectly fine to be inspired by
someone else’s book. It’s ok to borrow elements here and there from someone’s work,
as long as you’re not just ripping it word for word from their writing. But
outright stealing someone else’s ideas is something no writer should ever do.
Apart from the fact that it’s an incredibly lazy way of getting an idea, it can
be really hurtful to other writers.
Writing is a very solitary pursuit. We spend a lot of time
on our own coming up with characters and worlds, and pouring words out on the
page. So it’s very important for us as writers to be able sharing our books and
ideas with other writers so we can have support and companionship on the
journey. It can be hard enough for writers to gather enough courage to share their
writing as it is. Stealing someone else’s ideas breaks our fragile trust, and
makes it that much harder for writers to share their work next time, out of
fear of someone stealing their ideas.
The bottom line is, if you wouldn’t like it to happen to
you, don’t do it to someone else, no matter how good their idea is.
What Exactly Is Idea Stealing?
Idea stealing is when you see what someone else is writing, then take their ideas and use them as your own. It's usually only a big problem when it's obvious where the ideas have come from, or when an entire plot has been stolen. There’s nothing new in writing, so it’s not unusual for two
writers to write a book with a very similar concept. It’s the way the idea is
handled that makes the story unique. But starting from the same idea and stealing
a whole plot are two different things.
Stealing
“Hey, I love what you’re doing with your story about people
genetically modifying dinosaurs and creating dragons. In fact I like it so much
I’m going to have a go at writing it myself. But the main character’s name is
going to be Joe, not Chuck. It’s going to be completely different.”
Not Stealing
“Hey, I love what you’re doing with your story with people
genetically modifying dinosaurs and creating dragon. I’d love to do something
similar, only it won’t be dinosaurs but horses, and actually it’s going to be
set way in the future, so they’re more like robot ponies and let’s add this
handful of other things while we’re at it.”
It’s ok to be inspired by someone else’s idea, as long as
you don’t just take it verbatim. If you’re just copying someone’s idea
directly, then you’re stealing, especially if you don’t ask for permission. If
you like an idea and are inspired by it, go for it, but you have to make it
your own Just changing a couple of details doesn’t count if the core of the
story is exactly the same.
How Do You Make Sure You’re Not Stealing Someone’s Ideas?
If you’re worried about whether you’re stealing someone’s
idea, there are a few ways to tell whether you’re borrowing inspiration, or
stealing from them.
Are they offering
this idea as inspiration? Some writers like to share writing prompts on
their blog, Pinterest, or social media. These are designed for you to use in
your own writing. If you’re taking an idea from one of these, you’re fine.
Is part of their own book? If the writer
is sharing some of their own work and you get inspired by one of the ideas, you
can still use, providing you’re not writing the exact same thing they are.
Being inspired and using a similar idea worked into the rest of your book is
not stealing.
How similar is what
you’re writing to what they shared? How much of your idea has come from
someone else’s book? How much have you changed it to make it your own? If you’ve
been inspired to write a book along similar lines, but have created a different
story and made the idea your own, you’re ok. If your book is recognisably taken
from someone else’s work, you’re probably stealing.
Have you taken a
large chunk of someone’s plot? Borrowing elements of a story is completely
different to stealing a whole plot. Writers borrow ideas from other books all
the time. We see a bit of a story we like and we borrow a bit from here and a
bit from there, mix it all up and make it our own. Taking a whole plot is a
different matter, and that’s what really hurts, because creating a plot takes
so much time and energy and love.
Have you borrowed a
concept, or a plot? Writing the same base concept and writing the same plot
are two different things. Harry Potter and Star Wars have the same base
concept: An orphan finds out they have powers and goes off to fight a huge
evil. That’s fine. Writing a story about a boy on a distant planet who meets an
old man who gives him a sword made of light and guides him on an epic quest
across the galaxy to defeat a great evil is just taking someone else’s plot.
And that’s not ok.
If you’re worried,
check with the writer to see if they’re ok with it. If you’re worried that you may have stolen another writer’s
idea, talk to them about it. Explain what idea you liked, what you’ve done with
it, or plan to do with it to make it different, and see whether they mind. Most
writers are really nice people, and if you show that you’re inspired and
working to make the idea different and unique, they usually won’t mind. But it
never hurts to check if you’re concerned.
Ultimately, if you take an idea and work on it and make it
your own, then you should be safe. Stealing ideas is a lazy way of getting a
plot without working for it. Having your ideas stolen can be a pretty upsetting
experience though. And in part 2 I’m going to be talking about what you should
do if your ideas are stolen.
Do you agree with what
I’ve said? What issues would you like me to cover in part 2? Have you ever had
your ideas stolen? How do you make sure that you’re not just stealing someone
else’s ideas? Looking forward to part 2?
13 comments
Super awesome post! Stealing ideas is really really bad and hurtful. Thanks for sharing this post because a lot of times people (including me) don't know if it is stealing or being inspired.
ReplyDeleteNabila // Hot Town Cool Girl
It can be hard to tell sometimes, can't it? My biggest yardstick is always, how much of an effort have I made to adapt the idea to my own uses? If I've actively worked to make it my own, or to fit it into my own book naturally (which is different to just tacking it on because no idea fits perfectly the first time) then I'm less worried about whether it's stolen, because I've had to work at using the idea. I'm so glad you liked this post!
DeleteBLESS THIS POST. Honestly I always find it hard to decide whether I'm stealing ideas, whether it's for my novels, blog posts, anything really. And I rarely ever tell anyone else my ideas, fearing that they will take them. I have had my ideas stolen and it's honestly the worst feeling when someone takes your ideas and I really can't stand it when I see it. I don't think it's the same story if the idea for it was stolen from someone else, it just feels fake.
ReplyDeleteFor my Camp NaNo fanfiction, I took the idea from a post on Tumblr describing this Harry Potter AU that I really liked. I made sure that I ask boxed the blog before I began writing. I think the most foolproof way to make sure you aren't stealing any ideas, is to ask if you feel a little shaky about it.
Great post, as always, Imogen :)
~Noor
So glad you liked this post Noor! One tip I've found really helpful is that if you have an idea, sit on it for a bit and let it grow and adapt in your mind before you write it. That way you have time to make it your own, rather than rushing out to write exactly what inspired you to begin with. Good ideas need time to grow. I definitely agree with asking to use ideas if you're worried about stealing them. Thanks for visiting, Noor!
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis was a really interesting post, Imogen! I recently started writing a book about angels and demons, and after reading The Mortal Instruments I got SERIOUSLY paranoid that I was unknowingly plagiarising that work. But after reading this, I realise that I haven't: I just got inspired.
ReplyDeleteThank you for this post Imogen, it was just what I needed! I'm definitely looking forward to part 2 :).
ReplyDeleteHaving ideas stolen is definitely pretty horrendous and I get it a lot with my blog sadly. :( It's just super disappointing to be working hard at being original and creative and turn around and see yourself being emulated somewhere else. GAH. With blogging though it's more instantaneous. With writing? I honestly don't worry about it as much! I know NO ONE will write like I will, so even if I share my ideas, I know nobody else is going to pull them off like I would.😂 But I get so so mad when I read actually published books that rip other books off!! Like I read one the other day (Titans by Victoria Scott) that like 90% rips off The Scorpio Races by Maggie Stiefvater! I even outlined all the plot elements that were identical and it was disturbing. 0_0 I think we writers need to be careful that we also don't accidentally copy/steal from our heroes. I'm terrified I'll accidentally do that someday!
ReplyDeleteI used to copy and change ideas when I was little, but then I later thought up my original ideas. I've once suspected someone of stealing ideas from me, when she kept creating characters that resembled mine after I introduced a new one to her. That was annoying.
ReplyDeletestoritorigrace.blogspot.com
Fortunately I haven't had my ideas stolen, but I think there's a lot of blurry lines. This especially is a big deal when the debate arises on whether fan fiction is copyright infringement or not. I think in terms of plot stealing, I think it all depends... For example, Harry Potter and Star Wars and Eragon and many other fantasy stories all have the same plot, but that's because they're all working around a particular trope. So, if the idea surrounds a well-established trope, I could see there being some gray area.
ReplyDeleteUgh, I love this post. Idea stealing really bothers me, not only because it's a form of laziness, because it discourages another person's writing. I've wondered a few times if someone has stolen some blog ideas from me (but, like, it wasn't clear-cut enough to confront anyone about it), but I haven't had any book ideas stolen from me, to my knowledge, so that's a relief. But I'm also really paranoid about what I share online for that very reason, because while I am the sort of person who wouldn't take an idea because a) it's wrong and b) I don't even like to use writing prompts because they weren't my ideas, I don't trust half of the writers out there. I'm looking forward to reading the next post. (And also, sorry I've been away for so long--I won't get a chance to comment on too many of your old posts, but I will at least try to catch up on reading them as soon as possible.)
ReplyDeleteGreat post! For beginner writers is can be hard to even notice that your great story idea is actually a duplicate of your favourite work. It's an important lesson to learn. It's good to be inspired, but not to the point of copying.
ReplyDeleteThis is a good thing to keep in mind. I've never really worried too much about people stealing my ideas, but I'm pretty sure if I saw it happen once, then I'd be more paranoid. I try and make sure I don't steal other people's ideas, although I do borrow and switch stuff often enough. :)
ReplyDeleteAidyl from Noveltea